Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories, has sparked considerable controversy in the Netherlands with her latest report, From Economy of Occupation to Economy of Genocide.
Remarkably, the backlash is not primarily about the content of her report, but rather the panic it has triggered among right-wing politicians, pro-Israel lobbyists, and defenders of the status quo.
Her analysis of the “genocide economy,” in which she links Israel’s actions in Gaza to economic interests and systemic violence, has clearly struck a nerve. And rightly so – because speaking the truth disrupts the comfort of silence.
In her report, Albanese not only documents the large-scale destruction of lives, infrastructure, and livelihoods in Gaza, but also exposes how this devastation is systematically intertwined with economic interests: arms sales, military technologies, surveillance industries, reconstruction contracts, and geopolitical deals. She doesn’t just speak of genocide as a moral failure – she shows that, for some, genocide has become a business model.
That is not an “extremist” claim, as her critics allege. It is a factual observation, supported by sources, data, and international legal frameworks. Instead of engaging with these arguments, her opponents choose to demonise her.
Targeting the truth
Albanese is far from the first to face such attacks. Those who speak out for Palestinian rights – whether UN officials, academics, journalists, or activists – are routinely smeared. The strategy is clear: shift the focus from the message to the messenger. Accusations of antisemitism, terrorism sympathy, or conspiracy theorising are used to shut down any substantive debate.
But worse still: this erases the voice of the Palestinian people. Because this report is not about Albanese – it is about a people who have lived for decades under occupation, siege, and bombardment. It is about lives being erased – sometimes literally – and suffering being swept aside in public discourse.
Why this matters
As DiEM25 in the Netherlands, we stand firmly with Albanese and her courageous work. Not because we follow every word uncritically, but because she is doing what is essential in any just world: she refuses to look away. She speaks truth to power. She refuses to bow to diplomatic convenience.
As Julian Assange has said: “If wars can be started by lies, peace can be started by truth”. Truth, however, is often uncomfortable – especially when it reveals that war is not a mistake, but a system. A system fuelled by political complicity, economic gain, and ideological framing.
A call to progressive forces
We call on progressive parties, media outlets, and citizens not to let this moment be hijacked by right-wing spin. Instead, let us engage seriously with Albanese’s report – study it, discuss it, and use it as a starting point for the only question that truly matters: how can we contribute structurally to a just peace for both Palestinians and Israelis?
That begins by listening to those brave enough to speak out. And that courage deserves not scorn, but solidarity.
DiEM25 Netherlands stands for peace, human rights, and democracy – even if that means swimming against the tide.
Do you want to be informed of DiEM25's actions? Sign up here
