Susan Abulhawa’s powerful response to the Oxford Union’s Israel debate

On 28 November 2024, the Oxford Union held a debate on the motion: “This House believes Israel is an apartheid state engaged in genocide.” As is customary, two opposing panels presented their arguments before the audience voted by walking through designated doors. The motion passed by 278 votes to 59.

Among the speakers supporting the motion was Susan Abulhawa, a Palestinian-American novelist and human rights activist. She agreed to participate on the written condition that her speech would be published unedited.

Susan Abulhawa’s speech at the Oxford Union

Before I start, I will not be taking any points of information, so kindly refrain from interrupting me.

Addressing the challenge of what to do with the inhabitants of the land, Chaim Weizmann, a Russian Jew, said to the World Zionist Congress in 1921 that Palestinians were akin to “the rocks of Judea”, obstacles that had to be cleared from a difficult path.

David Gruen, a Polish Jew who changed his name to David Ben-Gurion to sound relevant to the region, said: “We must expel the Arabs and take their places.”

There are thousands of such conversations among the early Zionists who plotted and implemented the violent colonisation of Palestine and the annihilation of its native people.

But they were only partially successful. They murdered or ethnically cleansed 80% of Palestinians, which meant that 20% of us remained: an enduring obstacle to their colonial fantasies.

This became the subject of their obsessions in the decades that followed, especially after conquering what remained of Palestine in 1967. Zionists lamented our presence and debated publicly, in all circles, what to do about us: about Palestinians’ birth rate and our babies, whom they dubbed a demographic threat.

Benny Morris, who was originally meant to be here, once publicly expressed the view that David Ben-Gurion “didn’t finish the job of getting rid of us all”, which would have resolved the issue they refer to as the Arab problem.

Benjamin Netanyahu, a Polish Jew whose original name was Benjamin Mileikowsky, bemoaned a missed opportunity during the 1989 Tiananmen Square uprising to expel large swathes of the Palestinian population “while the world’s attention was focused on China”.

Some of their proposed solutions to the nuisance of our existence included the “break their bones” policy of the 1980s and 1990s, ordered by Yitzhak Rabin, a Ukrainian Jew who changed his name from Yitzhak Rabinowitz for similar reasons.

That horrific policy, which crippled generations of Palestinians, did not succeed in making us leave. Frustrated by Palestinian resilience, a new discourse arose, particularly after a massive natural gas field worth trillions of dollars was discovered off the coast of northern Gaza.

This new discourse is echoed in the words of Colonel Efraim Eitan, who said in 2004: “We have to kill them all.” Arnon Soffer, an Israeli so-called intellectual and political adviser, insisted in 2018 that “we have to kill and kill and kill, all day, every day”.

When I was in Gaza this year, I saw a little boy, no more than nine years old, whose hands and part of his face had been blown off by a booby-trapped can of food that soldiers had left behind for Gaza’s starving children. I later learned that they had also left poisoned food for people in Shuja’iyya.

In the 1980s and 1990s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up.

The harm they do is diabolical, and yet they expect you to believe that they are the victims. Invoking Europe’s Holocaust and screaming antisemitism, they expect you to suspend fundamental human reason and believe that the daily sniping of children with so-called kill shots, the bombing of entire neighbourhoods that bury families alive and wipe out whole bloodlines, constitute self-defence.

They want you to believe that a man who had not eaten anything in over 72 hours, who kept fighting even when he had only one functioning arm, was motivated by some innate savagery, irrational hatred or jealousy of Jews, rather than the indomitable yearning to see his people free in their own homeland.

It is clear to me that we are not here to debate whether Israel is an apartheid state engaged in genocide. This debate is ultimately about the worth of Palestinian lives, our schools, our research centres, our books and our art. It is about the worth of the homes we worked all our lives to build, which contain the memories of generations. It is about the worth of our humanity and our agency, our bodies and our ambitions.

Because if the rules were reversed, if Palestinians had spent the last eight decades stealing Jewish homes, expelling, oppressing, imprisoning, poisoning, torturing, killing and raping Jews;

If Palestinians had killed an estimated 300,000 Jews in one year, targeted their journalists, thinkers, healthcare workers, athletes and artists, bombed every Israeli hospital, university, library, museum, cultural centre and synagogue, and simultaneously set up an observation platform where citizens came to watch their slaughter as though it were a tourist attraction;

If Palestinians had corralled hundreds of thousands of Jews into flimsy tents, bombed them in so-called safe zones, burned them alive, and cut off their food, water and medicine;

If Palestinians had made their children wander barefoot with empty pots, gather their parents’ flesh into plastic bags, bury their siblings, cousins and friends, and sneak out of their tents at night to sleep on their parents’ graves; if they had made those children pray for death just to join their families and avoid being alone in this terrible world;

If we had terrorised them so utterly that their children lost their hair, their memories and their minds, and caused children as young as four or five to die of heart attacks; if we had mercilessly forced premature babies in neonatal intensive care units to die alone in hospital beds, crying until they could cry no more, then dying and decomposing in the same spot;

If Palestinians had used wheat flour and aid trucks to lure starving Jews before opening fire on them as they gathered to collect the day’s bread;

If Palestinians had finally allowed a food delivery into a shelter full of hungry Jews, then set fire to the entire shelter and the aid truck before anyone could taste a bite of food;

If a Palestinian sniper had bragged about blowing up 42 Jewish kneecaps in one day, as one Israeli soldier did in 2019;

If a Palestinian had admitted to CNN that he had run over hundreds of Jews with his tank, their crushed flesh lingering in the tank’s treads;

If Palestinians had systematically raped Jewish doctors, patients and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks, and fire extinguishers, sometimes raping them to death, as happened to Dr Adnan al-Bursh and others;

If Jewish women had been forced to give birth in filth, undergo caesarean sections or have their legs amputated without anaesthesia; if we had destroyed their children and then decorated our tanks with their toys; if we had killed and displaced their women and then posed in their lingerie; if the world had watched the systematic annihilation of Jews being livestreamed in real time;

There would be no debating whether that constituted terrorism or genocide.

And yet two Palestinians, myself and Muhammad El-Kurd, showed up here to do just that, enduring the indignity of debating those who think our only life choices should be to leave our homeland, submit to their supremacy or die quietly and politely.

But you would be wrong to think that I came here to convince you of anything. This House’s resolution, although well-meaning and appreciated, is of little consequence in the midst of this Holocaust of our time.

I came in the spirit of Malcolm X and James Baldwin, both of whom stood here and in Cambridge before I was born, facing finely dressed, well-spoken monsters who harboured the same supremacist ideologies as Zionism: notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favoured, blessed or chosen.

I am here for the sake of history, to speak to generations not yet born, and to chronicle this extraordinary time in which the carpet-bombing of defenceless indigenous societies is legitimised.

And I also came to speak directly to Zionists here and everywhere.

We let you into our homes when your own countries tried to murder you and everyone else turned you away. We fed you and clothed you; we gave you shelter, and we shared the bounty of our land with you.

And when the time was right, you kicked us out of our homes and our homeland. Then you killed, robbed, looted and burned our lives.

You carved out our hearts because it is clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the vilest of human impulses.

But the world is finally glimpsing the terror we have endured at your hands for so long, and people are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been.

They watch in utter astonishment at the sadism, the glee, the joy and the pleasure with which you conduct, watch and cheer the daily destruction of our bodies, our minds, our future and our past.

But no matter what happens from here, no matter what fairy tales you tell yourselves and the world, you will never truly belong to that land.

You will never understand the sacredness of the olive trees that you have been cutting down and burning for decades, just to spite us and break our hearts a little more.

No one native to that land would dare do such a thing to the olives.

No one who belongs to that region would ever bomb or destroy ancient heritage such as Baalbek or Battir, or destroy ancient cemeteries as you destroy ours, including the Anglican cemetery in Jerusalem and the resting place of ancient Muslim scholars and warriors in Mamilla.

Those who come from that land do not desecrate the dead. That is why my family, for centuries, were the caretakers of the Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives, as an act of faith and care for what we know is part of our ancestry and our story.

Your ancestors will always be buried in your actual homelands of Poland, Ukraine and elsewhere around the world, whence you came, and in Yemen.

The mythology and folklore of the land will always be alien to you.

You will never be literate in the sartorial language of the thobes we wear, which sprang from the land through our foremothers over centuries. Every motif, design and pattern speaks to the secrets of local lore, flora, birds, rivers and wildlife.

What your real estate agents describe in their high-priced listings as “old Arab home charm” will always hold, in its stones, the stories and memories of our ancestors who built those homes.

The ancient paintings and photographs of the land will never contain you.

You will never know what it feels like to be loved and supported by those who have nothing to gain from you and, in fact, everything to lose.

You will never know the feeling of masses of people all over the world pouring into streets and stadiums to chant and sing for your freedom.

And it is not because you are Jewish, as you want everyone to believe, but because you are violent colonisers who think that your Jewishness entitles you to the home my grandfather and his brothers built with their own hands, on land that had been in our family for centuries.

It is because Zionism is a blight on Judaism. It is a rupture in humanity.

You can change your name to sound relevant to the region.

You can pretend that falafel, hummus and za’atar are your ancient cuisines, but in the recesses of your being, you will always feel the sting of this epic forgery.

That is why even drawings by our children, hung on a wall at the United Nations or in a hospital ward, send your leaders and lawyers into hysterical meltdown.

You will not erase us, no matter how many of us you kill and kill and kill, all day, every day.

We are not the rocks that Chaim Weizmann thought you could clear from the land. We are its very soil, its rivers, its trees and its stories.

All of this was nurtured by our bodies and our lives, through millennia of continuous, uninterrupted habitation of that patch of earth between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. From our Canaanite, Hebrew, Philistine and Phoenician ancestors to every conqueror or pilgrim who came and went, who married or raped, loved or settled, enslaved or converted between religions, or prayed in that land, all left pieces of themselves in our bodies and our heritage.

The fabled, tumultuous stories of the land are quite literally in our DNA. You cannot kill or propagandise that away, no matter what death technology you use or what Hollywood or corporate media arsenals you deploy.

Someday, your impunity and arrogance will end. Palestine will be free, and she will be restored to her multi-religious, multi-ethnic, pluralistic glory.

We will restore and expand the trains that run from Cairo to Gaza, Jerusalem, Haifa, Tripoli, Beirut, Damascus, Amman, Kuwait, Sana’a and beyond.

We will put an end to this Zionist-American war machine of domination, expansion, extraction, pollution and looting.

And you will either leave, or you will finally learn to live with others as equals.

Thank you.

Do you want to be informed of DiEM25's actions? Sign up here

Kaja Kallas and the EU’s seven dwarfs: Another diplomatic farce

Something happened in the European Union on Tuesday. Next to insignificant in geopolitical terms. But morally, politically it was something that ...

Read more

US taxpayers charge Donald Trump and Marco Rubio with aiding and abetting genocide

On Wednesday, November 11, a number of representatives of the American organisation Taxpayer Alliance Against Genocide (TAAG) and international ...

Read more

If I were Chancellor: Britain doesn’t have to stay broken

Opposition politicians critical of the sitting chancellor always have an ambitious plan to rebuild Britain – until they move into No. 11. ...

Read more

Abby Martin joins DiEM25 livestream: Who pays for the war machine?

Abby Martin, one of the most prominent independent journalists exposing the realities of US imperialism, joins Yanis Varoufakis for our latest ...

Read more